Keurig Kcup Recipe- Pumpkin Butter

Posted on Mon, Oct 07, 2013

How to make Pumpkin Butter using Keurig Kcup Apple Cider

And the pumpkin recipes continue.  I am an absolute pumpkin fool in the fall. My family has been inundated with pumpkin cookies, muffins, pie and the piece de resistance...pumpkin butter made with Keurig Kcup Apple Cider!

Let's get to the recipe...

You will need:

1 Apple Cider Keurig Kcup

3 1/2 C pumpkin puree

2t vanilla extract

1 C brown sugar

2 T cinnamon 

dash of nutmeg

dash of cloves

Keurig Kcup Pumpkin Butter with bite

-Start by brewing your Apple Cider Keurig Kcup on the middle or lowest water setting of your Keurig brewer.

-Combine all ingredients in a sauce pan.

-Bring to a boil (this will happen very quickly). 

-Reduce heat and let simmer for 30 minutes.

Transfer to a glass jar and you are ready to enjoy!

Pumpkin butter is not as good as apple butter it is WAY better in my humble opinion.  The flavors are much more intense and absolutely tickle my taste buds! I enjoy spreading a generous amount on toast or adding it to my oatmeal. 


What about you, are you team apple or team pumpkin?

Purchase Seasonal Keurig K-cup Coffees



Most popular posts

gray bar
Keurig® Brewing for Beginners cover
gray bar
gray bar

Heavenly flavors, remarkable fall aromas!  Hurry, it won't be around for long, order now!


🖱️Buy Pumpkin Spice K-Cup® Coffee